Not currently logged in. [Login or Create an Account]

To Feed or Not to Feed . . .

By Ed Fuentes
Published: Monday, July 16, 2007, at 08:47AM

SkidRow SLO Ed Fuentes [Flickr]

LAPD Senior Lead Officer Deon Joseph has been working Skid Row for a number of years. He uses the LAPD blog to bring up topics, and now adds something many might not have considered an issue. He wants the volunteer groups, mostly from churches, who come from outside Downtown to distribute clothing and food for Skid Row residents to know that they may be leaving long term problems behind. Joseph writes in To Feed or Not to Feed, An Important Question:

"Homeless feeders" still come down to skid row by the dozens and give out paper bags full of food, and throw plastic bags full of clothing onto the sidewalks. They do not recognize that one of the driving forces keeping many of the homeless on skid row is the flourishing narcotics trade. When they are finished doing their good work, the homeless individuals in question remove their halos and begin bartering their food items and clothing for narcotics.

< snip >

When these streets look like a dump, people are more inclined to dump other items such as sanitary napkins and human waste on the sidewalk, creating one of the unhealthiest environments in the City of Los Angeles. Sometimes glass items are given to the homeless in the form of soda or other refreshments. These items are later used as weapons that cause injuries to other homeless individuals. Fights often break out over these items as they are being distributed, not because they are desperate for food or clothing, but because they trying to find the best item to sell for money in order to buy crack cocaine, heroin, or marijuana.

Joesph goes on to say that no one has really been cited if the intention is good, and he understands that making a difference is the motive. As one church-goer I know of who comes from 2 hours away tells me, they enjoy "seeing the face of someone being helped."

It's just that there are better ways to do it. Officer Joseph leaves his contact info at the end of his post for anyone who wants to ask how.

SHARE:

Tweet This Story || Share on Facebook


Conversation

 

Tim on July 16, 2007, at 09:41AM – #1

I give money to the Mission every month instead of giving money, food or clothing directly to individuals. It seems to be the best way to help address the problem without contributing to it.

They have a website and you can set up a monthly recurring:

https://lv0.net/Form/LAMission/2003


 

Urban Bruin on July 16, 2007, at 10:14AM – #2

By just “giving” away food or other items of value without the need to work (i.e. help cook, clean up or administer the distribution) devalues the item that is given. “Charity giving” without more only helps to enable the very people the charity is trying to help to remain in the condition which they need help to get out.

“Give a person a fish and they will eat that day. Teach them to fish and they will never grow hungry”



Add Your Voice


COMMENT GUIDELINES:
Keep it civil, everyone. If you're attacking people instead of arguments, or being overly profane, expect your comment to get deleted.
Comments should be on topic for the story they are posted on or they will be removed.
Use the live preview below to see how your comment will look before posting.

YOUR IDENTITY:

Either sign in below or just skip down to the comment box and type away. If you don't sign in, your comment will be left under the name "Guest."

Why sign in? We believe that the best conversation takes place between people, not between randomly-created pseudonyms.

Email:

Password:

 



COMMENT:
FORMATTING BASICS:

blogdowntown uses Markdown formatting.

_Italics_
__Bold__
<http://url.to.link>
[link text](http://url)

PREVIEW:

Start typing...