blogdowntown
Not currently logged in. [Login or Create an Account]

Stay Connected



 

Police say there was no crime in Spring Street bike accident

By Hayley Fox
Published: Tuesday, April 10, 2012, at 04:50PM
Jennifer Beatty via Twitter

Susanna Schick recovering in hospital bed.

A Spring Street involving a woman who was seriously injured while riding Downtown last Friday, may not be as clear-cut as previously reported on the web.

Although multiple outlets have alleged that the collision was a hit-and-run, the Los Angeles Police Department says they are not filing it as such.

"There's a great deal of discrepancy," Lt. Paul Vernon of the Los Angeles Police Department said. "There is no crime here. She fell down on her bicycle."

Susanna Schick, , was riding down Spring Street at around 11:30 p.m. Friday when a car pulled out of a garage, swung wide and swerved into the bike lane. That part of the event is not in dispute.

According to Schick's own statement, she doesn't think the car hit her, Vernon said. But when both parties arrived at the next red light, Schick pedaled up to the car, hit the side view mirror and began yelling at the people inside, who reacted by rolling up their windows, according to the report.

Vernon says that two police officers witnessed the incident and reported seeing Schick continue on her bicycle for another block or two until the car turned right and she wobbled and fell over, tumbling off the bike. The two police also say that there was no collision with a car.

It was these officers who were the ones to call the ambulance, Vernon explained. They also returned Schick's bike to her house.

According to and many news , however, Schick did not merely fall off her bike but was rammed from behind by the midsize car after she had been harassed by the passengers in the vehicle.

Police say that no witnesses have come forward in relation to the incident. Schick was unavailable for comment.

Jennifer Beatty, Schick's friend said that it was a "physical improbability" that Schick's bike could become so damaged without a collision. Beatty described the damage to the rear wheel as being a "bike taco" bent half an inch -- and further explained that Spring Street is mostly smooth with no drains or other obstacles that would have caused Schick's bike to get the wobbles.

Beatty also said that the police department didn't take Schick's report for almost three days after the injured cyclist had suffered a concussion and had been "in and out of it."

Schick's injuries are not disputed; she was wearing a helmet but still suffered a concussion.

In addition to breaking her collarbone, Schick, 42, also broke her pelvis and six ribs and is still recovering at USC County Hospital.

Schick has received an outpouring of support from friends and the bicycling community, via and the organized by BikeLA.

SHARE:

||


Conversation

User_32

stevejust on April 10, 2012, at 10:09PM – #1

KPCC: Please obtain the police report. The idea that an experienced cyclist could have an accident while wearing a helmet that involved 1) a concussion 2) a broken pelvis, 3) six broken ribs and 4) a taco'ed rear wheel strains credulity.

This whole thing smells porcine.


User_32

stevejust on April 10, 2012, at 10:13PM – #2

Sorry, to clarify: I meant a single-person accident not involving an outside force. For example, like being swiped by a white Lexus making a right-hand turn.


User_32

on April 12, 2012, at 03:17PM – #3

Physical evidence should tell the story. Bike taco = impact. Being an attorney who has read hundreds of police reports, they are not always accurate. In fact, the law already contemplate the potential for error in a police report; police officer opinions are not admissible in court.

-


Sun W Kim on July 05, 2012, at 09:11AM – #4

As an experienced biker, if you keep your calm about you when dick drivers cut you off or swerve into your lane (for whatever reason), this wouldn't happen. Car vs bike, CAR WINS.



Add Your Voice


In an effort to prevent spam, blogdowntown commenting requires that Javascript be enabled. Please check your browser settings and try again.

 


blogdowntown Photo Pool

Photos of Downtown contributed by readers like you.

Downtown Blogs


Downtown Sites


Elsewhere