blogdowntown
Not currently logged in. [Login or Create an Account]

Stay Connected



 

Improving Skid Row: Mayoral candidates and activists weigh in

By Rachel Garcia
Published: Tuesday, August 28, 2012, at 04:41PM
Photo via cd13.com

L.A. City Councilman Eric Garcetti said he wants to form a coalition of businesses, faith institutions, government, everyday residents and nonprofit organizations in order to solve the problems in Skid Row.



Operation Healthy Streets, the city's latest effort to clean up Skid Row after it violated several health codes, consists of routine scrub-downs and trash removal in order to maintain the area. In light of clean-up efforts and the 2013 race for mayor of Los Angeles, Blogdowntown spoke to mayoral candidates as well as activists about their efforts, plans and hopes for the Skid Row.

Eric Garcetti, L.A. City Councilman and 2013 Mayoral Candidate:
"Skid Row has been a local problem. It has been a national embarrassment," Garcetti said.

As mayor, Garcetti said he would focus on three S's when dealing with Skid Row: Services, structures and stories. He said he would focus on providing services for people in Skid Row because services turn peoples' lives around. In terms of structures and stories, he said that you need to learn people's stories to find out who is the most vulnerable or close to death in order to prioritize housing placement.

"Individual case management is a model to end homelessness," he said about the imperative of getting to know the people who live on Skid Row.

Garcetti said he wants to form a coalition of businesses, faith institutions, government, everyday residents and nonprofit organizations in order to solve the problems in Skid Row.


Wendy Greuel, L.A. City Controller and 2013 Mayoral Candidate:
Greuel says she has a unique perspective on Skid Row after working with the U.S. Interagency Council on Homeless to help conduct some of the first counts of homeless populations.

She said her focus will be creating permanent housing with attached social services in order to ensure health and safety for homeless in Skid Row.

Greuel said she will also focus on providing services to prevent people from becoming homeless in the first place.

"This will take financial resources fro the federal, state and local governments as well as excitement from the business community," she said.


Kevin James, 2013 Mayoral Candidate:
James has two main action points for dealing with Skid Row - auditing the money that is directed towards Skid Row and converting city facilities into housing for area residents.

He wants to audit money that is designated for Skid Row in order to expose corruption.

"We need honest answers about where taxpayer money is going," he said. He added that public money that could be going to Skid Row is being lost and, as mayor, he would work to reconcile the money he claims is being squandered.

James also wants to create more housing for the area's residents.

"We have city facilities that could be retrofitted to shelters for the homeless," he said. He suggests, for example, transforming closed hospital facilities into affordable housing.

When deciding who to provide with housing, James suggests separating people by priority level. The first priority, he said, should be families with children. Then he describes those who seem to be easiest to re-acclimate to society - those who want jobs and can be trained. The final priority, he said, should be drug users, those who are mentally ill, as well as the chronically homeless.

"Some people will never take well to assistance," he said. "We have to separate those who want housing and jobs from those who do not."


General Jeff Page, Skid Row resident, activist and self-proclaimed "Mayor of Skid Row":
"Skid Row is the dirtiest, nastiest, filthiest place in the whole world," Page said.

Page suggests paying Skid Row residents to do the work performed by Operation Healthy Streets.

He also said that the area has a large pedophile problem. Combined with a growing number of children in the area, he said that housing families with children should be a major priority.

"I'd like to see the buildings transform into having offices and retail on the ground with the floors above it used as housing for Skid Row residents. The roofs could be used as outdoor play areas so kids can run around outside with less concern about predators.

Page also said that the area needs to implement more "positive programs."

"The easiest way to get rid of negative energy is to create positive energy," he said, applying his college physics education to the situation in Skid Row.

He recommended exercise programs for the area's residents including low-impact exercise equipment for senior citizens.

"The proper way to rehabilitate people is through health and nutrition," he said. He explained that while the missions do an invaluable service in feeding people, he would like to see them try to serve healthier meals instead of focusing on just filling people up.


Katherine McNenny, Skid Row loft resident and activist:
"A lot of people in the Skid Row community know me as the Tree Lady," McNenny said.

McNenny's main goals are adding more trees and greenery, benches and art to Skid Row.

"Our streets are so hot," she said. "People are burning up."

McNenny said that Skid Row needs to have more safe places open at night, after the parks and missions have closed. She wants people to start talking about making public spaces safer for Skid Row's mentally ill population and suggested the implementation of outreach teams who can attend to them

"People in Skid Row need places to go to at night that they can afford," she said. She suggested opening 24-hour coffee shops as a safe place for Skid Row's homeless population.


Jan Perry, L.A. City Councilwoman and 2013 Mayoral Candidate:
As councilwoman, Perry oversaw Downtown, including Skid Row, for 11 years until redistricting took effect in July.

Perry said that, as mayor, she would continue the work she did as councilwoman in the area by continuing to create public housing. Also, she said she would work with the city as well as L.A. County to improve the resources given to the homeless.

"The next mayor needs to make sure the community gets the respect it deserves," she said.

She added that she would collaborate between businesses, homeless and community interests in order to make sure Skid Row is respected.

"It will be difficult if you make it difficult but not if you set it out as a priority," Perry said.

SHARE:

||


Conversation

User_32

zeMinimalist () on August 28, 2012, at 11:06PM – #1

DTLA can't be the lone place for most of the regions problem people. Skid Row is in effect a controlled ghetto with agencies more interested in attracting more problem people than they are helping the existing people. This all needs to be reversed and market rate developments should be mixed in with what's currently in skid row. This will dismantle the ghetto and also reduce the density of problem people, which will help those in need.

As it currently stands, people with drug problems are surrounded by people with drug problems. Pedophiles are surrounded by pedophiles. People lacking job skills are surrounded by people without skills.

If you read up on the history of the modern day Skid Row, it was a decision by LA to isolate or ghettoize the problem people so the rest of the region didn't have to deal with them. It wasn't about improving the lives of the people there, it was about isolating. There was no one for decades in DTLA to say, "not in my backyard", as the rest of the region was harking. When there's a problem person in some part of LA, they get dumped into Skid Row, that's can't happen.

The good news is, with more people moving to Downtown, private money will soon dwarf the hand full of skid row players and justice will be served. Not a single new skid row housing development should be built in skid row, they should be built throughout the rest of the region, in everyone's back yard, only then will we find out how people REALLY feel about these problem people. And I only call them problem people because these people are dependent on a thriving city just to survive. Without the mass wealth of LA, they'd likely be left on the side of the road without any services because services require lots and lots of money.


Christopher Eaton on August 29, 2012, at 01:01AM – #2

zeMinimalist hits the nail directly on the head. Could not agree more. Every part of L.A. County has to do its share to deal with the homelessness problem, which is not just L.A. County's burden to share but that of the nation-we bear the brunt of that burden because of our weather. No more facilities should be built (meaning missions). I'm all for mixed use facilities but I feel that there is a massive group of institutions in DTLA that are committed to perpetuating the homelessness problem in DTLA because their funding and jobs are predicated upon that. In other words, let's keep the homeless homeless. That day is done. A new era is dawning. No one neighborhood should shoulder this burden. Let's invest in these neighborhoods, let private development take root, develop projects like the New Genesis across the street from my loft, and disallow the despair and ridiculous conditions that no large city in America puts up with, including NYC or Chicago, cities to which I travel frequently. Every part of DTLA belongs to everyone. The Homelessness Industry doesn't own any part of DTLA, nor should it.


User_32

keenast on August 29, 2012, at 02:33AM – #3

OMG, them politicians are talking (including the self proclaimed 'General'). All of them (including the 'missions' and 'sro's are busy making money, wash their hands in innocence and do business as usual. Nobody really gives a sheet about the ghetto, all pay lip service.

The ghetto, and a shame it is, will only go away if it is de-zentralized, and only then and in smaller doses will it be possible by the various communities to integrate those that need help and weed out those that don't.


User_32

John G on August 29, 2012, at 08:07AM – #4

@ zeMinimalist

Well said! I agree. Providing assistance for the homeless is still important but the bigger picture is how we develop this area for the future.

Do we still keep it as an area for help or do we incorporate it with the rest of downtown as a thriving global city? I have heard stories where even bums in Louisiana are bussed to downtown L.A. on one-way tickets. So tell us L.A. City Council, how will you address this?

I don't think the homelessness problem will ever be solved because that is like saying we can get rid of crime. What's important is how we transform this area so that it can be like the rest of the city - vibrant, growing, and developing. People can complain about displacement, but no one "owns" or "controls" public space, especially the sidewalks everyone is entitled to use.


User_32

Pershing was a square on August 29, 2012, at 11:38AM – #5

I also think skid row needs to be decentralized, for the good of all. It can't the single go to place for anybody getting out of jail, has a mental illness, or a drug habit. It just can't. At times it feels like an outdoor asylum. That said, downtown is big enough for everyone and I'm all for smaller, newer developments that have housing and services in the same location for people who want help. These should spread across all of the downtown area and not concentrated. Having worked with mentally ill people I'll say this; I've seen people who weren't all that sick get worse by being around crazier people. I think that model applies not only in the settings I worked in, but to large scale neighborhoods like skid row.


User_32

Mario Teran on August 29, 2012, at 01:35PM – #6

I have the answer. Rent a fleet of buses and take them up to San Francisco. I've been up there so many times over the years and SF seems to be open to homelessness. They even had a program years ago where they were paying homeless.


Brigham Yen on August 29, 2012, at 06:06PM – #7

I agree 100% with zeMinimalist, Chris Eaten, keenast, basically everyone who has commented above me here. Not another single homeless mission should be built in Downtown LA's Skid Row and the ultimate goal must be "De-centralization." Why should Downtown LA carry the burden of this entire metropolitan region? It's completely unfair to everyone including the homeless who deserve to recover in a nurturing environment that isn't a concentrated "ghetto of poverty."

The next Mayor of LA really needs to do what New York City was able to accomplish. For those who remember, Grand Central Terminal in Manhattan used to be home to 5,000 homeless on any given day/night. Anyone who has been to New York recently knows the situation has improved -- drastically.


User_32

Pershing was a square on August 30, 2012, at 08:13AM – #8

Is there any chance there could be a debate or a Q&A held in downtown about downtown with the mayoral candidates? Where we could pose real questions to them?


User_32

Vio V on September 02, 2012, at 08:55PM – #9

I agree with most of the comments that propose decentralization of Skid Row. However, it seems to me that none of the mayoral candidates share these ideas. Skid row should not simply be "improved", it should be wiped out from the face of the city. In its place we need to enable a functioning, safe community, not a dumping site for the city's homeless and mentally unstable. This should definitely include more housing and services to help the homeless, but not necessarily in this part of the city.

Obviously, a change of this size would require a a feat of extraordinary policy making. I'm not asking for miracles, but I will wholeheartedly campaign for a mayoral candidate who can give me a plan for Skid row that is at least a move in the right direction.

I am relatively new DTLA resident and am not sure of the best approach to make my opinion heard. I will first try to attend the Downtown Neighborhood Council meetings to see if that is the right channel.


User_32

John G on September 02, 2012, at 10:49PM – #10

Vio V, thanks for sharing your opinion and choosing DTLA as your new home. Council meetings are a great forum to share your ideas. I have attended several city council meetings myself. Although your opinion may be heard, just remember that there are many other outreach and coalition groups out there that may not want Skid Row removed at the rate we would like it to be; all for the sake of social justice, discrimination, and unfair so-called "displacement".

It would be better if you and other residents (and/or business owners) who share the same opinion got together to spread the message out. I have seen so many NIMBYs in my neighborhood effectively block developments because they got together and made a loud political statement to the council members. This is the strategy for many of these people - forming groups to send out loud political messages.

Suggest working with other people and representing a group - it's much more effective than speaking as an individual. Just my two cents from what I've seen and heard.



Add Your Voice


In an effort to prevent spam, blogdowntown commenting requires that Javascript be enabled. Please check your browser settings and try again.

 


blogdowntown Photo Pool

Photos of Downtown contributed by readers like you.

Downtown Blogs


Downtown Sites


Elsewhere