blogdowntown
Not currently logged in. [Login or Create an Account]

Stay Connected



 

Fashion District's Other Illegal Inventory: Animals

By Ed Fuentes
Published: Friday, August 21, 2009, at 09:27AM
Rabbits_A Ed Fuentes

Near Santee Alley, baby rabbits with no protection from the heat wait to be sold. Selling animals has been a visible, and illegal, industry since the 1990s.



At the corner of 12th and Maple, two stacks of cages sit in the mid-afternoon August sun. Inside are baby rabbits with underdeveloped legs –– barely supporting their body weight –– shaking on top of wilted lettuce leaves.

On top are plastic aquariums occupied by young turtles. When a buyer asks to see a turtle, they are handled with jarring hands that cause the animal to panic, making them seem healthy and active to a potential pet owner.

While crackdowns on counterfeit designer wares and pirated DVD sales bring media attention and large fines, the Fashion District's illegal animal trade continues unabated.

According to a report by the City Attorney's office, many of the small animals found in the Fashion District, mostly near Santee Alley, are bred in rural animal farms as far away as Temecula. They are then transported to Los Angeles to be stored near Downtown, waiting to sold by vendors who are closely monitored by what could be referred to as pet cartels.

"We have been working with LAPD and Animal Services, trying to remove illegal sales since 1999," said Lynn Myers, General Manager of the Fashion District Business Improvement District. "It's cruel treatment of animals." Often conditions keep the animals near death, Meyers added.

Randall Tampa, Operations Director for the BID, has seen those conditions many times. "You will see these rabbits in small cages, in the hot sun, with only lettuce and carrots," said Tampa. "They are supposed to be fed pellets, and are sold malnourished."

Once the un-weaned baby rabbits are sold, some as young as a few days old, new pet owners discover their bunnies have diarrhea. "What people are buying are animals at the end of their lives," explained Tampa.

Sometimes the pet owners simply return and purchase another, and turnover is constant. "Animals have been found caged," said Tampa. "They are packed in vans sitting in lots with no protection from the heat."

Due to dense fur on bunnies, experienced pet owners keep a frozen bottle of water in the cage a rabbit can cool themselves. Walking by cages on Maple this past week, baby rabbits were seen only protected by shade provided by the upper cage, if they were lucky. None had water nearby, and many were sitting quietly, listless with fast shallow breathing; the first signs of heatstroke.

Health risks apply to humans as well. Turtles are often contaminated with salmonella. They are so contagious at a young age that turtles with shells smaller than 4 inches long have been illegal to sell or distribute in the U.S. since 1975.

"It's hard for kids to walk by when the animals are so cute," said Patricia Hernandez, shopping for summer wear with her three children. "I may have to give in one day."

When someone asked how much for one baby rabbit, the bunny vendor said "Twenty Dollars!" while looking around. Prices are known to fall to five dollars with negotiation.

While animals are sold year round, the peak season is Easter. That's when vendors add appeal by dressing baby rabbits in outfits, and ducks are added to the inventory of hamsters, iguanas, lizards and turtles, plus exotic birds smuggled in from southern Mexico.

Currently, fines for breaking ordinances on selling illegal pets are $25, doing little to discourage sales.

LAPD Senior Lead Officer Randy McCain, who has enforced laws on illegal sales in the Fashion District since 1994, noted that arrests are made complicated when parents assign their children to be the front person in selling the small animals –– thwarting an immediate arrest. Still, arrests have been made, with Animal Control present to handle the rescue.

One afternoon of raids in the last few weeks collected more than 55 animals. That number hardly wiped out the population, according to Tampa. "We could easily reach that number everyday," he said.

Even when rescued, most animals are short of options. The Animal Cruelty Task Force, Animal Control, and the Department of Animal Regulations have few resources to find them homes.

Luckily, the baby rabbits have a caretaker in Lejla Hadzimuratovic, an actress and former member of PETA who was assaulted last year after taking photos of animal vendors at 12th and Maple. She and two other members of her group were battered by individuals who jumped out of a car to protect their investment.

Despite news coverage and an investigation, no charges were filed by Newton Division, she said. The incident did, however, prompt her to form an organization, now operating as the non-profit , to heal and help find homes for newborn rabbits sold in the Fashion District.

"We are still working closely with LAPD," said Hadzimuratovic, who is making a documentary on the animal sales near Santee Alley. "Since June 2008, we have saved 450 baby rabbits, and found homes for 250 of them."

A quick walk around the Fashion District shows that the group still has a long way to go.

SHARE:

||

Related Stories:


Conversation

Guest 1

ryan on August 21, 2009, at 10:02AM – #1

Any tipline to call when you see one of these vendors?


Eric Richardson () on August 21, 2009, at 10:33AM – #2

That's a good question, Ryan. I suspect that the answer is that the sales aren't hard to find, but that there isn't the manpower to be constantly doing enforcement. We'll ask, though.


Jamie DeFrisco on August 21, 2009, at 10:38AM – #3

I'm glad you posted this. I've seen these sellers around and always wondered how they got away with this.

I would also like to point out that a lot of people buy these animals without fully thinking it over. The rabbits, in particular, look small and cute, but in time they start to grow into much bigger animals. You can't keep them in a small cage in a room for long. Then they end up in shelters. Last time I went to a shelter they had a ton of rabbits.

It's bad enough to be selling animals on the streets, but I'm surprised that police can't do anything about the kids selling animals. Wouldn't it be considered child labor? There has to be something they can do.


Guest 1

Belinda on August 21, 2009, at 10:55AM – #4

It's not a violation of child labor laws if the kid is a family member. Frankly, that's the least of anyone's worries. The illegal vendors should be arrested. I'm tired of LA turning into a third world country.


Beth Topping on August 21, 2009, at 11:43AM – #5

So sad and absolutely cruel. Is there a way to get involved? I agree with Belinda -- it's so unfortunate that more community resources can't be used to shut this down.


Guest 1

Fashion District on August 21, 2009, at 12:22PM – #6

There are a number of reactive responses for those that are concerned - one is to call the BID ()and we will alert and work with the LAPD in an effort to rescue the animals.

Beth, one way to help is to partner with Lejla at the Bunny World Foundation (please go to her web site).

Proactively speaking, if you see a pending sale, attempt to dissuade the parent from making the purchase. I constantly inform parents they are purchasing an animal that has little chance of survial and/or is going to make their children sick. If there is no market for these animals, the vendor will (hopefully) abandon their animal selling trade!

Randall Tampa, LA Fashion District


Jim Winstead on August 21, 2009, at 12:40PM – #7

i've noticed that there is a pet shop, or at least sometimes signage for one, near the corner of 5th and los angeles. i hope they are a legitimate store that treats their animals better.


Guest 1

Brian on August 21, 2009, at 03:27PM – #8

Great article - we've come across these vendors on numerous occasions and wondered how they can sell animals on the sidewalk. You know damn well they are not in good health and it's incredibly cruel.

I've also been surprised with the number of puppies being sold throughout downtown - people walking around with them in their arms and asking people if they are looking for a dog. One hot day (90+) at The Americana in Glendale a guy walks across the street and opens a zipped duffel bag to pull out a puppy that he begins selling.

Like everything else in LA there is periodic enforcement but little deterrent. Make the fine something signifcant, $1,000 or more for a first offense. Prosecute a few individuals and send the word this will no longer be tolerated.


Guest 1

Captain Blake Chow on August 21, 2009, at 05:12PM – #9

Good coverage Eric. We have a text to tip line that one can use as follows if one wishes to remain anonymous.

to text a tip to the Los Angeles Police Department, you must have text messaging enabled on your phone and subscribe to a participating cell phone carrier. To begin your tip session, text the word "LAPD" along with your crime information to the number, , which spells the word "CRIMES" on your phone's keypad.

While handset menus differ by carrier or model, here are some basic steps on how to compose a text message .

Find "Messaging" or "SMS" on your phone's menu.

  1. Create a new text message or send text or SMS text.

  2. When composing your message:

Enter the number as the mobile # or in the "to" line. In the message body, type the word LAPD, a space, and then your crime tip information (LAPD is not case sensitive).

  1. Hit "Send" to send the message.

  2. You will receive a response from TipSoft shortly, which will start the secure text dialogue.

For your safety, when you complete your tip submission, you should always delete all text messages to and from from your text message in box and out box.

The other alternative is to send me and email at . I will not disclose the author but rather have it worked under cover.

We have been doing regular taskforces with our City Attorney and working to obtain civil stay away orders also; so that just being in that location is a violation of a court order and thus arrestable.

I just returned from a search warrant we served in the Fashion District where we recovered 5,000 illegal DVDs and arrested at least 3 people. We will continue to work the problem with the community.


Guest 1

Sarah on August 22, 2009, at 08:36AM – #10

Thank you, Ed, for writing this story! I was on the downtown walk with you last week when we saw these bunnies... I hope your article does some good! Thank you!


Guest 1

Jane De Haven on August 22, 2009, at 09:12AM – #11

Thank you for running this article. My daughter and I have volunteered at Bunny World Foundation, run by Lelja Hadzimuratovic, and her efforts are nothing short of heroic. She spends a great deal of her own money, time, and energy in saving these rabbits. Literally, she barely sleeps and is spending hundreds of dollars a month to shelter, feed, and medicate these bunnies. Antibiotics are needed, at the cost of $150 per bottle, because these bunnies are so young, unweaned as the article pointed out, and can get sick to the point of death due to the terrible neglect they suffer. My daughter and I have spent three hours at a time handfeeding the babies with eyedroppers, then giving them medicine with a syringe, but what we do is just a drop in the bucket compared to the daily need. Bunny World Foundation gives a chance to these small creatures to experience a clean and healthy environment for the first, and sometimes the only, time in their tiny lives.


Guest 1

Chris on August 22, 2009, at 12:31PM – #12

Shame on them. Disgusting!!!!


Guest 1

American Tortoise Rescue on August 22, 2009, at 02:40PM – #13

Here's the video we made and a description.
http://bit.ly/14sZ26 http://www.tortoise.com/id31.html We have tried to clean this mess up for years. Contacted many a reporter who came down with us and then the story got buried. Before it opened I was assured by the Business District animals would never be sold - garbage. It is a hot bed for illegal goods and animals. And the Business District likes it like that - it brings the crowds to buy from the area residents - remember these people do not collect sales taxes either. 10 years later it is no different - a bunch of rampant criminals dealing in poor animals. Notice the blasting music? That's to keep the birds and lizards moving around in horror to make them look healthy. BTW - you could be knifed down there when you take photos or video - have tried and have been threatened - and no one would notice or care.
The only person who seemed to really care was Ed Boks at LA Animal Services and now some crazy animal people drove him to retire. Contact this nice guy - he can help. Capt. Wendell Bowers North Central Center


Guest 1

chattycathy on August 22, 2009, at 03:57PM – #14

God be with you Ed for reporting this story, and to all of the wonderful people who care for these poor animals. Can we spread the word that anytime these dying animals are seen, that anyone has permission to call "311" and report these dying animals to animal control?


Ashley Raj on August 22, 2009, at 08:56PM – #15

I really hope this article makes a difference because this should really be unacceptable! Disgusting behavior...


Guest 1

Brice Chiu on August 22, 2009, at 09:09PM – #16

These illegal sales of animals needs to be stopped. I hope this article brings media attention to the issue. The animals are not receiving the care they need and new owners and not receiving the proper adoption education that they need.


Guest 1

browne on August 22, 2009, at 10:06PM – #17

The selling of animals period should be banned. This pet accessory crap is a sick trend and I hope it stops.

While we are at shutting down the "third world" I hope we all remember James Rudis of Overhill Farms in Vernon, he processes chickens (and ruins people lives and fires the people who support the people who he fires for crappy reasons.) It's a pretty barbaric process. I actually hope all of you who are very disgusted by the "third world" people and “their” practices that it's truly not so much about "those" people, but the animals. I hope you are also very concerned with the many eateries that are serving meat and the grocery stores that sell meat and the lotions and pet food like Iams that are tested on animals. As a vegan I find this all very disturbing.

I hope you all take all of this concern and go after people who are hurting way more animals than these people and their little store fronts in downtown LA.

You know what I think, I think this has nothing to do with the animals I think it has to do with something else and that's what I will continue to think when anyone who wears leather shoes and eat chicken, steak and fish starts acting completely outraged about animal abuse.

I'm not saying it's horrible, but I don't believe why you are all so concerned.

Browne


Guest 1

catherine spitz on August 22, 2009, at 10:25PM – #18

please stop doing this! how can we find protection for these poor animals? Who can help?


on August 22, 2009, at 11:13PM – #19

Sorry Brown. I won't agree with you, nor sit back. Pet ownership is not exactly a "trend" and both people and pets benefit from that relationship.

No one brought up the issue of "third world" culprits. You did, and as a Latino, I find that comment potentially highly offensive. I will not debate you further on it.

The purpose of this post was to let people know there is a case of constant animal abuse in the Fashion District, and in the case of rabbits, there is a way to help through the bunny foundation.

It's also to let others know to discourage anyone who wants to buy an animal from a street corner (not a storefront if you read carefully).

Committing to being a vegan is a topic for another post, that I am not qualified to write.

Brice: The same topic was covered by KTLA Saturday evening.


Diana Fleig on August 22, 2009, at 11:18PM – #20

These animals are separated from their mothers much too soon. The carrots or lettuce in the cages are only for show; the infant rabbits' digestive systems cannot handle anything but milk. The vendors don't even provide water for them!

The volunteers at Bunny World Foundation, in particular Lejla, work to save these victims of unethical trade, providing medicines, milk, and care. This takes an incredible amount of dedication, time, and money. Recently, they took in 30 infants at once, which were handed over in a plastic garbage bag! All of these babies require 'round-the-clock care, including twice-daily feedings of formula.

If you are interested in adopting rescued rabbits or making a donation to aid the cause, please check out http://www.bunnyworldfoundation.org. They desperately need our help. One can of formula, which will feed 30 babies for about 4 days, costs $26.00.

Any move towards eradicating animal exploitation is a positive one.


Guest 1

Browne on August 23, 2009, at 12:21AM – #21

Ed if you are offended you need to talk to Belinda (4) since she said it first and you didn't seemed outraged about it then.

I would assume someone would make a comment about that (obviously to me) insulting statement, but nothing, which is why I made my statement.

Do you not see it? She said something to paraphrase, "I'm sick of downtown looking like the third world."

Oh maybe she said it differently than me.

And Ed my dad is from the Honduras so that would make me a Latina, but that doesn't really give me more right to say something than someone else, but if you think genetics makes people more qualified on different topics then I guess since my mom is Nigerian you got me beat on Latino. You win.

I was simply bringing up an observation and my thoughts on the "concern" for the little animals.

Browne


on August 23, 2009, at 12:37AM – #22

Thank you for your observations.


Guest 1

Animal Welfare Act on August 23, 2009, at 06:24AM – #23

This is a federal issue and should be reported to the proper authorities:

http://awic.nal.usda.gov/nal_display/index.php?info_center=3&tax_level=3&tax_subject=182&topic_id=1118&level3_id=6735&level4_id=0


Guest 1

Sherri on August 23, 2009, at 08:33AM – #24

Ed, great work on this story! Can you somehow make sure that someone from PETA gets to read it? This is so inhumane...keep up the excellent reporting!


Guest 1

Been There on August 23, 2009, at 09:08AM – #25

Jim W, I've been to the pet place on Winston just east of Los Angeles (on the south side of the street). It is no better. The place is tiny, packed with crowed cages, windowless and unventilated. They set their animals in cages out on the sidewalk during the day, sometimes with water and sometimes without.

The animals poop on the sidewalk when they are out during the day. It is not cleaned up. Later at night homeless people flop down on that sidewalk and sleep for the night (or sell and use drugs and alcohol).

This pet shop should be shut down.


Guest 2

Jon on August 24, 2009, at 10:13AM – #26

Don't want to get too off topic, but whil) e I disagree with Browne's take on the gold line (on the eastside blog), I'm in perfect agreement with her here. Though we could be wrong. Perhaps for some pe ople "illegal animal trade" by itself conjures up images of third world countries. I'd like to think the demographics in the Fashion District aren't what eli cit comparisons to "third world", but that's probably naive.


Qathryn Brehm on August 24, 2009, at 12:09PM – #27

Thanks so much for starting this discussion on the animal neglect and cruelty.

For many years Downtown has been a place where dogs and cats have been dumped when they were no longer needed or wanted. It was not uncommon to see dogs wandering suffering from malnutrition.

Many downtown artists did what they could to rescue and adopt. There are many organizations including Downtown Dog Rescue who have done some great work with this problem.


Guest 3

anthony costantino on August 24, 2009, at 02:21PM – #28

Ed,

Get over your racial touchiness. Just because someone mentions "Third World" doesn't mean it applies only to Latinos. It's about a certain standard of living. Most of us in LA, Latinos included, want something better other than people having to make a living by exploiting animals.


Guest 4

Randall BusTard on August 24, 2009, at 03:11PM – #29

I started to read through the comments, but upon the author's first rejoinder I noticed that he had not read the comments before commenting ON the comments (otherwise the writer would know who first brought up "third world"—and it was not Browne), so I thought, "If the person who penned this piece will not others' comments before answering, why should anyone read the article before commenting?"


Guest 5

Jon on August 24, 2009, at 03:19PM – #30

I think you meant me, not Ed (who appears pretty adamant against bringing up race when it isn't merited). Perhaps there is something uniquely "third world" about the illegal animal trade. But hey, the standard of living on skid row is pretty terrible as well, yet I don't hear too many comparisons to the third world there. So "third world" is just a reference to standard of living, eh? Maybe skid row and "third world" are just different categories?


Guest 4

Randall BusTard on August 24, 2009, at 03:37PM – #31

In comment #3, Belinda wrote: "I'm tired of LA turning into a third world country."

In a comment further down, Browne wrote: "While we are at shutting down the 'third world...'"

In responce to Browne, Ed wrote , Ed incorrectly pointed out: "No one brought up the issue of "third world" culprits. You did..."

So I suppose I do read the comments. There goes my acting stupid so as to act as if I am leveling the playing field, eh Jon?


on August 24, 2009, at 04:18PM – #32

After a series of emails with Brown, I stand corrected and apologize here for making the accusation that she brought up the third world comment.

I want to keep the topic on point before it escalated to themes of racism and elitism.

However, to respond to a few points. Pets as an accessory trend is odd description of something that has been in practice for a long time. And if not being vegan or using any other animal product is considered as cruel, I will admit it is subject often discussed, but has nothing to do with this topic.

Bus: I'll be glad to discuss this with you in person, a very level playing field, and more suitable than this thread.

One last add for Anthony, you can go to any post I have ever written anywhere and you will not find anything that could ever be remotely confused with "racial touchiness."

And to everyone else, please keep it on topic, and as we at blogdowntown clearly state in comment guidelines; keep it civil.


Guest 6

anthony costantino on August 24, 2009, at 07:15PM – #33

I'm new and glad to have met everyone :)


Guest 4

Randall BusTard on August 25, 2009, at 05:53AM – #34

"Bus: I'll be glad to discuss this with you in person, a very level playing field, and more suitable than this thread."

Indeed. And as I have in the past given you my card, certainly you know where to reach me in private, that we may discuss this in person.


on August 25, 2009, at 11:39AM – #35

That card was a while back. Pass along your contact info through , or use the email address brownie used a few days ago.


Guest 7

Valida on August 27, 2009, at 04:31AM – #36

I am so glad that someone has finally written this article. I just hope it doesn't end with this. Seeing a tiny baby bunny die of malnutrition or because it's underdeveloped (a product of being separated from their mother too soon...these babies need their mother's milk just as much as humans) is heartbreaking to witness. Lejla has seen it much too often at her bunnyworld rescue operation and it needs to end.

Thank you for bringing attention to this.


Guest 8

Linda Baley on October 13, 2009, at 08:54AM – #37

FANTASTIC !!!! THANK YOU FOR YOUR HELP ON THIS -

I am only sorry to be chiming in on this story so late....

As a rabbit rescuer in Redondo Beach (TooManyBunnies.com) I have personally been the recipient of over 30 of these bunnies. They arrive on my doorstep, nearly dead, often with mites and coccidosis (an intestinal parasite) The family members that bring them are stunned, alarmed, guilty and grieving. HORRIFIC!

It takes a lot of money, work and time to try and save them. I succeed about 1 time in 5 with these guys.

People who manage to get the animal to adult hood face some extra issues:

If the families who purchased these bargain pets were to go to a vet, the bill would likely be over $1,000.00 - after that the going rate to fix a rabbit in Redondo Beach is $330.00. Unfixed rabbits, both male and female spray like male cats to mark territory. They use scent glands by their private parts to give the spray and their urine a skunky odor. Unlike fixed bunnies, unfixed are almost impossible to litter-box train.

Babies bunnies reaching adulthood often will find out they hate each other and try to kill each other, in the process removing or severely maiming eyes, noses, ears and genitalia.

That won't prevent them from mating though - Rabbits start to have babies at 4 months of age and do it every 28 days. Because their Y-shaped uterus has 2 cervixes, they can get pregnant again WHILE giving birth.

Imagine that - the breeders of these downtown bunnies keep the mothers pregnant ALL THE TIME. I have seen the cages that the Does live and give birth in - they are too small for the mother rabbits to stan up in or to lie down and stretch out. They have just enough room for a one foot x one foot plywood whelping box and a food dish and water bottle outside. The cage itself is wire, approximately 2' x 16" x 16". Want to see my pics and hear that story? email me. The average litter is from 6-12 babies. In one year, one bunny can be over 2000!

Did I mention that rabbits life span is from 8-12 years.

When they are healthy enough and old enough to be fixed we pay for the surgery and then litter box train them and adopt them out FREE to loving homes - These guys have been through enough, already ,they don't need to sit in cages at my rescue because some nice family can't afford a donation. Also, there are always more coming my way. I can't afford to keep them, and I don't have the space - there are so many more......

The folks who sell these animals have a special place in my heart , they are the ones that provide me with a full time job where I pay money to work my tail off. The kicker - I am only one of many "Crazy Rabbit Rescuers" who have been equally blessed.

Anyone wanting more info on this wonderful set of pics from the rescuer's side can contact me at


Guest 9

Kimberly on November 01, 2009, at 06:12PM – #38

This is horrible and must be stopped. Linda/anyone, what else can we do?? (I admit I have not read ALL the comments, if anyone wants to reiterate concisely what we can do and what we can ask our friends to do?).


Madeleine Fisher-Kern on May 17, 2011, at 05:41PM – #39

There seems to be a disconnect between the ability to crack down on sellers of counterfeit Pradas and Louis Vuitton handbags which has been far more successful than the crack down on the illegal animal trade. One would think that the high end designer handbags have more clout than those who wish to see those responsible for the illegal animal trade get another line of work. Is it the big payoff from an obvious syndicate who probably deals in a lot of illegal substances? What ever it is, it is despicable that our law enforcement in the city of Los Angeles can't stop this cruel and health hazardous sale of hapless creatures who are the major sufferers in this game.



Add Your Voice


In an effort to prevent spam, blogdowntown commenting requires that Javascript be enabled. Please check your browser settings and try again.

 


blogdowntown Photo Pool

Photos of Downtown contributed by readers like you.

Downtown Blogs


Downtown Sites


Elsewhere