blogdowntown
Not currently logged in. [Login or Create an Account]

Stay Connected



 

Designs for Broad Museum Focus on 'The Veil' and 'The Vault'

By Lauren Mattia and Eric Richardson
Published: Thursday, January 06, 2011, at 10:15AM
The Broad Diller Scofidio + Renfro

The design for The Broad opens at 2nd and Grand, where guests are led onto an escalator that takes them up to the third-floor gallery.



Today a Downtown crowd got its first look at renderings for The Broad, the $130-million Bunker Hill museum that will be built to house Eli Broad's 2,000-piece collection of contemporary art.

The design by Diller Scofidio + Renfro focuses on "the veil" and "the vault" — the honeycomb lattice that will comprise the exterior of the building and the second-floor space that will house the majority of the collection not on display.

Visitors to the structure will enter at 2nd and Grand, taking an escalator ride up through the building's second-floor archive vault to the 40,000-square-foot gallery space above. The column-free design is touted as providing almost an acre of uninterrupted space, allowing maximum flexibility for the art displays.

“Our goal for the museum is to hold its ground next to Gehry’s much larger and very exuberant Walt Disney Concert Hall through contrast,” said architect Elizabeth Diller in a press release. “As opposed to Disney Hall’s smooth and shiny exterior that reflects light, The Broad will be porous and absorptive, channeling light into its public spaces and galleries. The veil will play a role in the urbanization of Grand Avenue by activating two-way views that connect the museum and the street.”

Today’s press conference revealed in-depth architectural plans to over 200 city officials at Walt Disney Concert Hall.

Speaking first was Eli Broad himself, who thanked his wife of 56 years, who is also the co-founder of the Broad Art Foundation. Broad also thanked the mayor, who he called “a champion of the arts.” Broad also introduced the 12 member board for the museum, 11 of whom were present for the conference.

Villaraigosa noted that the Broads were “a part of the fabric of the city,” and that years ago, Broad “talked about the dream of Disney Hall, which seemed like a pipe dream.” The Concert Hall opened in 2003. Broad believes his namesake museum will open its doors in early 2013.

Following Villaraigosa was Councilwoman Jan Perry, who hailed the renderings as “an inspiration to us all,” and thanked the Broads “for their precious gift.”

Community Redevelopment Agency Chairman Ken Fearn assured guests that the collaboration will “bring another cultural icon to Los Angeles.” Fearn stressed the revitalization that the museum will stimulate, commenting that its development will create 1300 construction jobs and 100 permanent jobs. He also stated that a parking facility under the museum will help the surrounding area.

Liz Diller of Diller Scofidio + Renfro presented the renderings, who said that her company was challenged with the “great responsibility to provide a sound home for the [Broad] collection,” and added that they stayed close to the original vision of the Bunker Hill area while planning to offer an interesting contrast to the architectural icon that is Walt Disney Hall. Renderings show the Broad museum with a matte, porous structure that Diller said will contrast with the Walt Disney Concert Hall’s smooth, metallic lines.

The architect also said that the sidewalk adjacent to the museum would be widened to accommodate the 200,000 visitors the museum is projected to receive yearly.

Broad said that construction is set to begin by mid 2011, with a projected opening in early 2013. The Broad museum's inaugural exhibition will feature 200 of the Broad collection's most memorable works from the 1950s onward.

Flythrough Video

SHARE:

||

Related Stories:


Conversation

Guest 1

Guest on January 06, 2011, at 10:36AM – #1

I approve...looks like it's breathing


Ken L. Hall on January 06, 2011, at 10:41AM – #2

I think the outside is ugly, the white precast concrete will be impossible to keep clean and (in LA's smog)will look dirty in no time...plus, the honeycomb design will attract pigeons...this is not a good design for the outside of the building. As with so many buildings downtown, it only invites people in from one or two corners of the structure. More glass is needed along all sides at street level to attract people to look and be able to enter from the street...entering up a concrete "hole" doesn't seem very inviting to me. The building is called "The Broad"...well, she's an ugly broad, right from the start.


Brigham Yen on January 06, 2011, at 11:12AM – #3

I love it and can't wait to see the Broad come to fruition!

...Just thinking about the future phases of the Grand Ave Project...If the museum is a fraction of the size of what was intended to go on that parcel, hopefully it means that the OTHER parcels will automatically get "density bonuses" (from air rights perhaps?) that allow for larger projects in the last remaining lots. Especially since we may need to relocate the seismically damaged County Buildings in the future.

My main concern rests with the County Buildings (the courthouse and admin building) preventing the Grand Park from really tying together all the disparate properties into one cohesive urban context. The park's borders should be in direct access of not only the Music Center, but the Cathedral on the north (blocked by the admin building) and the future Grand Ave Project to the south (blocked by the courthouse).

Relocating the badly damaged county buildings would increase the size of the park tremendously (just imagine the size of each building's foot print), and really provide a substantial amount of green space that is more than the current narrow strip of park proposed.


Guest 2

Guest on January 06, 2011, at 11:38AM – #4

The final slide credits City Hall to A.C. Martin, but wasn't it actually Parkinson?


User_32

rob on January 06, 2011, at 11:58AM – #5

@ ken

where did you read that it will be precast concrete?


Thomas K Nagano on January 06, 2011, at 12:30PM – #6

Guest 2 is almost right: "The building was designed by John Parkinson, John C. Austin, and Albert C. Martin, Sr." It was completed in 1928. Some thought is was designed with too much parking under the building. - TK


User_32

Downtown Cowboy on January 06, 2011, at 12:41PM – #7

It is ugly. I heard it described as resembling "tripe". This design will attract dirt and pigeons (can't you just see a nest of pigeons in each of those alcoves?). I was hoping for more. sigh


Guest 3

Guest on January 06, 2011, at 01:15PM – #8

'The building is called "The Broad"...well, she's an ugly broad, right from the start.'

The Broad name is actually pronounced as "Brode," like road. It's not homonymous with broad, as in woman. Just an FYI.


User_32

Laldava02 on January 06, 2011, at 01:28PM – #9

I think it looks great! I'm excited to see this built. It will be a great addition to the area. I agree witb Brigham that the county building really need to go for the civic park to fully live up to it's true potential.


User_32

DavidAC on January 06, 2011, at 01:59PM – #10

Cool-looking building.

I hope they have a HUGE budget for cleaning!!


Ken L. Hall on January 06, 2011, at 02:51PM – #11

@Rob: The article in the LA Times reports that the exterior will be concrete, and you not would pour that shape of concrete in place, it would have to be pre-cast. This building reminds me of the American Cement Building from 1960 - http://la.curbed.com/archives/2009/07/american_cement_building_for_sale.php

It looks like a public building from the 1960's or 70's...horrible.


Guest 4

Guest on January 06, 2011, at 02:58PM – #12

I like it. Will be looking forward to seeing how it is in person once it's complete!


Guest 5

Guest on January 06, 2011, at 03:14PM – #13

Is there a rendering showing how this new building integrates itself into the architecture of the Disney Concert Hall? Or other neighbors?

Who's dollars go to the upkeep and maintenance of the exterior? I agree with comments above - it's gonna need TLC.

Some of the images evoke biology class text books - looking at cross-sections of skin with very large pores.


on January 06, 2011, at 03:25PM – #14

$130-million pigeon condo...


User_32

David McBane on January 06, 2011, at 04:28PM – #15

Ken L. Hall - I bet the building is going to use a new self-cleaning cement material called TX Active. Its first use was on a new church in Rome and it has stayed bright-white for several years now. It is a pretty amazing material.

See http://txactive.us/

So I think the concrete will stay clean in regards to smog. To keep out the pigeons, maybe the holes can be designed so they have a steep enough slope inside them so that the pigeons won't land in them.


Guest 1

Guest on January 06, 2011, at 05:46PM – #16

What a bunch of haters...this is a rad, forward looking design with nods of appreciation to the past! And sounds like the Broad folks are pushing to integrate the site with the surroundings and offer up public amenities (as they should given the sweet deal we gave them!), so I appreciate that.


User_32

rob on January 06, 2011, at 06:00PM – #17

@ Ken

Don't see anything about materials for the museum. I assume the museum will be a steel/ metal structure. Which could compliment the Walt Disney.

Although the flythrough video makes the museum exhibit space look small. Also with all those open pores would impact will the direct sunlight have on the art work?


Guest 6

Guest on January 06, 2011, at 06:11PM – #18

Bring back the lobby floor car ramp!


Guest 7

Guest on January 06, 2011, at 07:06PM – #19

They'll need liquid krypton to add to the cement mix to achieve a way-cantilevered concrete lattice with strength sufficient to keep the building upright in a strong earthquake. It reads as a veritable lace box. A powdercoat finish metal alloy lattice may be required instead.

I would not wish to be in that building during tectonic movements.


User_32

Disgruntled Goat on January 06, 2011, at 08:58PM – #20

I am sorry to join the opposition, but it looks to me like the architects were just trying too damn hard. It cannot be kept clean. The birds will roost, the particulates will settle, the design will age quickly. I think M/M Broad are LA's #1 citizens, I am delighted that they are willing to donate their money to the greater benefit of the city. I've been eagerly awaiting the museum design. But I am dissapointed. Maybe it will look better on the ground.


Guest 8

Guest on January 06, 2011, at 11:24PM – #21

All these people concerned about pigeons roosting. Broad is a builder, lets give the man some credit to figure out how to handle to birds. Awesome design. I'm thrilled! Looks like a mouth inside. Too cool for school.


Guest 9

Guest on January 06, 2011, at 11:44PM – #22

Just watched the flythrough video...this looks HOT!! Thank you Broads! An amazing gift for downtown.


User_32

DawnC on January 07, 2011, at 12:06AM – #23

I think this building looks amazing. Such a nice departure from all the steel and glass we've been seeing lately. Self-cleaning cement sounds totally futuristic, finally the aliens are landing in Downtown!

I also love the design of the American Cement Building. A friend of mine lived in one of those lofts and the huge windows with giant cement X's were amazing to gaze at the city through. I can only imagine the awesome effect of looking at the sky through this space-honeycomb.


User_32

Greensmark on January 07, 2011, at 09:59AM – #24

Down with the nay-sayers! You people need to take a nap! This is an awesome design. I am SO happy that this new museum will be downtown. Along with all the other incredibly designed buildings on Grand. Once again, we get a bunch of sad people with no taste, looking back instead of forward. We need this building to, once again, jump start the economy and the continuing advancement of downtown! I, for one, was thrilled to see the "fly-by". And that there are no columns in the structure: BRILLIANT!!

Grnsmrk~ PS: Was there a bunch of nay-sayers glucking when the Gehry designed Disney Hall was revealed???


Guest 10

Guest on January 07, 2011, at 02:24PM – #25

Would love to see a strong connection to the new Regional Connector station at this location.


Guest 11

Guest on January 08, 2011, at 05:56AM – #26

Well, well. Will the white concrete exoskeleton be assembled in sections or cast in place? They've already claimed outright that this skeleton IS the structural frame.

Concrete is great in handling compressive force. Not so great in handling stress and it is at it's greatest volume when it is poured. It begins to shrink ever so slightly as it hardens and sets up. That's why we see joints in sidewalk paving as well as in street curbs and walls of various sorts. These joints expand as the sections of concrete shrink.

You can use a maximum high strength cement mix. For reinforcing there is steel rebar and plastic fibers.

Mister Broad had ought to educate himself about the full nature and behavior of concrete and the potential hazards of the way his designer's intend to make use of it. Imagine all of the stress points imparted upon that lattice during sustained seismic shaking, all of the forces unleashed upon his structure in an 8.0 magnitude (1 minute plus) earthquake (particularly where those cantilevers meet the supporting garage structure). Any and all cracks will then admit moisture and what does moisture do to steel? True, they could use stainless or galvanized reinforcement, but THERE WILL BE CRACKS as well as spalling of concrete. Concrete has very little flexural ability as compared to metal.

Would Ove Arup or Santiago Calatrava come up with a design for concrete such as this????? All of those strands. The thinness or fineness of elements in these slices of elongated bubble foam forming the roof and sides, their susceptibility to stress which give cause for concern.

Don't get me wrong. I like the design. It would be great to be able to see it in all of its 3-D glory. But then I can't help but remember the sharpness of the quake as I stood below the north tower of Wells Fargo Center on an early morning of October 1st, 1987.

It would be interesting if structural engineers could weigh in and do combat on The Broad on Grand.


Guest 12

Guest on January 08, 2011, at 09:11PM – #27

Take another look, folks: rather than The Broad, maybe it ought to be called Moby Dick..... Obviously, it turns it's back to the plaza atop the garage. Will the parking garage relate to Hope Street the same way as does the World Trade Center to Flower Street? Getting people from the Connector station up and onto to the museum's plaza is quite a creative opportunity. How might the designers create something of a tail and use the blank rear wall in a manner similar to their museum in Boston?

If they can make the veil work, as we're being lead to believe, this building will be a technological leap and The Birds Nest and the Water Cube of the '88 summer Olympics do not compare. The 1905 reinforced concrete Leonardt Warehouse on Industrial Street propelled L.A. to the cutting edge in building technology. Unfortunate that Moby Dick could not have been designed here as well.


User_32

Accessory Loft on January 09, 2011, at 12:24AM – #28

Ick, looks like a bad design from the 60's. S + R are so overrated.


Guest 13

Guest on January 09, 2011, at 03:36PM – #29

If they can pull it off as like what we see in the renderings, the experience of being in the top-floor gallery will be like no other interior space that I'm aware of. With no beams or pillars, it will be otherworldly, will far outshine museum spaces designed by Louis Kahn, Richard Meier and Renzo Piano.

Movie directors will clamor to use the space.

But, just imagine standing beneath the cantilevered corner of the lattice facing Second and Grand in a large earthquake. Imagine the effect of seismic waves produced by the hidden thrust fault deeply buried under Downtown. Thrust faults produce vertical accelerations. That lattice will veritably bounce up and down in midair. The garage structure will have to be constructed atop isolators that can absorb and dissipate a huge amount of force. Yeah, they'll need Krypton alright!


Guest 14

Guest on January 11, 2011, at 11:24AM – #30

Wow, so many architects & structural engineers here! Think of all the money broad could have saved by just consulting commentators on this fine blog.


Guest 10

Guest on January 12, 2011, at 09:23AM – #31

@Guest 11: Nabih is on the job...



Add Your Voice


In an effort to prevent spam, blogdowntown commenting requires that Javascript be enabled. Please check your browser settings and try again.

 


blogdowntown Photo Pool

Photos of Downtown contributed by readers like you.

Downtown Blogs


Downtown Sites


Elsewhere